This exercise helps select a smaller number of indicators using some indicator criteria. You can modify it to incorporate any other criteria important in your community. You can also decide to use all three worksheets below or just one or two. The first one is for selecting good indicators, which are not necessarily 'sustainability indicators'. The second one is useful for selecting sustainability indicators and the third one is a sample report-back form.
 
C-6a  Useful, meaningful indicators
C-6b  Sustainability indicators
C-6c  Report Back Summary Sheet